Aloha is Calling: How to Choose the Perfect Hawaiian Island for Your Dream Getaway

Hawaii is the ultimate bucket-list destination—a paradise of sun-drenched beaches, lush rainforests, and breathtaking volcanoes. But with so many stunning islands to choose from, deciding where to go can feel overwhelming. Should you soak up the vibrant energy of Oahu, explore the dramatic cliffs of Kauai, or unwind in the luxury resorts of Maui? Luckily, we’ve done the research for you. Even better—use credit card points and miles to vacation for pennies on the dollar!

Each Hawaiian island has its own personality, from action-packed adventure to tranquil, off-the-grid escape. Whether you’re a first-time visitor, planning a romantic honeymoon, or looking for the best family-friendly getaway, there’s a perfect island waiting for you. Let’s dive in and find your dream destination!

 

Maui: The Perfect Balance of Adventure, Luxury, and Relaxation

Best for:

• Families & multigenerational trips
• First-time visitors
• Luxury seekers
• Snorkeling & diving enthusiasts

Maui is the ultimate middle ground—less crowded than Oahu but still packed with plenty to do. It’s home to some of Hawaii’s most iconic experiences, including the breathtaking Road to Hana, sunrise at Haleakalā, and world-class snorkeling at Molokini Crater. If you visit during winter, don’t miss the chance to spot humpback whales migrating through Maui’s warm waters.

The island’s west and south shores are known for their luxurious resorts, from the lavish Grand Wailea Waldorf Astoria and Andaz Maui to the family-friendly resorts of Ka’anapali like the Hyatt Regency Maui and the Westin Ocean Resort and Villas. Whether hiking through a bamboo forest, stargazing upcountry, or indulging in a beachfront luau, Maui delivers the best of Hawaii all in one place.

Top Experiences:

• Snorkeling at Molokini Crater
• Driving the scenic Road to Hana
• Sunrise at Haleakalā National Park
• Whale watching (December through April)

 

 

Kauai: A Nature Lover’s Paradise

Best for:

• Adventure seekers
• Romantic getaways and honeymoons
• Hiking enthusiasts
• Families with older kids

If untouched natural beauty is what you’re after, Kauai is calling. Known as the “Garden Isle,” it’s the greenest and most rugged of the Hawaiian Islands. Towering cliffs, cascading waterfalls, and emerald valleys define this dreamlike landscape. The Nā Pali Coast is one of the most spectacular sights in the world, whether you experience it by boat, helicopter, or hiking the famous Kalalau Trail.

Outdoor lovers will find paradise here—kayak down the Wailua River, explore Waimea Canyon (the “Grand Canyon of the Pacific”), or take in the views at Hanalei Bay. And while Kauai gets more rain than the other islands, the frequent showers only enhance its lush, tropical beauty. Use your points at the beautiful Grand Hyatt Kauai.

Top Experiences:

• Viewing the Nā Pali Coast
• Taking a boat or helicopter tour of the cliffs
• Exploring Waimea Canyon
• Relaxing at Hanalei Bay
• Kayaking down the Wailua River

 

 

Oahu: The Best of City Life and Beachside Bliss

Best for:

• First-time visitors
• Solo travelers
• History buffs
• Budget-conscious travelers
• Beach nightlife

Oahu is the heart of Hawaii, offering a dynamic blend of city life, historical landmarks, and breathtaking beaches. Honolulu’s famous Waikiki Beach is the place to be for surfing, shopping, and sunset mai tais, while the North Shore is home to legendary waves and charming beach towns.

History buffs will love visiting Pearl Harbor and exploring the rich Polynesian heritage showcased at the Bishop Museum. For a more laid-back experience, head to Ko Olina, where the luxurious Four Seasons offers a tranquil escape. For an affordable family trip, check out the Hyatt Regency Waikiki Beach Resort and Spa or the Hyatt Place Waikiki Beach.

Oahu is also the easiest island to fly into and the most affordable, with plenty of nonstop flights from the mainland. If you want a little bit of everything—culture, nightlife, outdoor adventures, and world-famous beaches—this is your island.

Top Experiences:

• Surfing and nightlife in Waikiki
• Touring Pearl Harbor and the USS Arizona Memorial
• Hiking Diamond Head for epic city views
• Driving along the North Shore’s scenic coast
• Snorkeling at Hanauma Bay

 

 

The Big Island: Volcanic Wonders and Outdoor Adventure

Best for:

• Adventure lovers
• Couples & honeymooners
• Hikers & nature enthusiasts
• Travelers wanting to see an active volcano

The Big Island is like Hawaii’s wild side—vast, diverse, and packed with jaw-dropping landscapes. Here, you can watch lava flow at Hawaii Volcanoes National Park, stargaze from the summit of Mauna Kea, and snorkel with manta rays at night. From black sand beaches to lush rainforests, the Big Island offers an entirely different side of Hawaii.

While many travelers stay on the sunny Kona side, the island’s Hilo region is home to stunning waterfalls, botanical gardens, and fewer crowds. Whether you’re chasing waterfalls, hiking through a lava field, or soaking in a natural hot spring, the Big Island is a paradise for adventure seekers. Check out a stay at the Hilton Waikoloa Village with points.

Top Experiences:

• Visiting Hawaii Volcanoes National Park
• Snorkeling with manta rays at night
• Hiking to Akaka Falls & Rainbow Falls
• Exploring Punalu’u Black Sand Beach
• Stargazing at Mauna Kea

 

 

Lanai & Molokai: Hawaii’s Hidden Gems

Best for:

• Travelers looking for off-the-grid escapes
• Returning visitors seeking something new
• Those who love small-town charm

If you’re craving a quieter, more remote Hawaiian experience, Lanai and Molokai offer something truly special. Lanai, once known for its pineapple plantations, is now home to two luxurious Four Seasons resorts, including an adults-only retreat. The island is small, but you can still explore rugged landscapes like the otherworldly rock formations of Keahiakawelo (Garden of the Gods) or snorkel in the pristine waters of Hulopo’e Bay. Lanai doesn’t offer any hotels that are bookable directly with points through a hotel program, but you could always use points to book through a travel portal or to erase a paid hotel stay.

Molokai remains one of Hawaii’s most untouched islands—even quieter than Lanai. There are no big resorts, no traffic lights, and no crowds—just authentic Hawaiian culture and stunning, undeveloped landscapes. For a truly off-the-beaten-path adventure, visit Kalaupapa National Historical Park, where you’ll learn about the island’s fascinating (and heartbreaking) history. You might want to use the Capital One points eraser feature for a stay at one of the hotels on these islands.

Top Experiences:

• Luxury retreat at the Four Seasons Lanai
• Snorkeling at Hulopo’e Bay
• Exploring Keahiakawelo (Garden of the Gods)
• Experiencing authentic Hawaiian culture in Molokai
• Visiting Kalaupapa National Historical Park

 

 

Which Hawaiian Island Is Right for You?

Still undecided? Here’s a quick cheat sheet:

• Oahu – Best for first-time visitors, city lovers, and history buffs
• Maui – Perfect balance of adventure, beaches, and luxury
• Kauai – Ideal for nature lovers and couples seeking tranquility
• Big Island – The ultimate choice for adventure and volcano lovers
• Lanai & Molokai – Hidden gems for those seeking true seclusion

No matter which island you choose, you’re in for an unforgettable Hawaiian escape. So grab your swimsuit, pack your bags, and get ready to say Aloha to paradise!

 

Related Posts

 Podcast 23. The Hawaiian Hyatt Showdown: Grand Hyatt Kauai vs. Hyatt Regency Maui

Friday Family Vacation to Oahu

Reader Success Story: Four Generations in Hawaii

Post-Christmas Celebrations to Hawaii With Points and Miles